Dáil Éireann - Volume 95 - 30 November, 1944 Suspension of Deputies.
The Taoiseach Eamon de Valera
The Taoiseach: I move:— That Deputy Larkin be suspended from the service of the Dáil. Question put.
1225
1226
[1225][1226] The Dáil divided: Tá, 74; Níl, 19. Tá
Aiken, Frank. Allen, Denis. Anthony, Richard S. Bennett, George C. Blaney, Neal. Boland, Gerald. Boland, Patrick. Brady, Brian. Brady, Seán. Breathnach, Cormac. Brennan, Thomas. Breslin, Cormac. Briscoe, Robert. Buckley, Seán. Burke, Patrick (Co. Dublin). Butler, Bernard. Carter, Thomas. Childers, Erskine H. Coburn, James. Colbert, Michael. Colley, Harry. Corry, Martin J. Cosgrave, Liam. Daly, Francis J. Derrig, Thomas. De Valera, Eamon. Dillon, James M. Dockrell, Henry M. Dockrell, Maurice E. Doyle, Peadar S. Flynn, Stephen. Fogarty, Andrew. Fogarty, Patrick J. Furlong, Walter. Giles, Patrick. Harris, Thomas. Hilliard, Michael. |
Hughes, James. Humphreys, Francis. Keating, John. Kilroy, James. Kissane, Eamon. Lemass, Seán F. Little, Patrick J. Loughman, Frank. McCann, John. McCarthy, Seán. MacEntee, Seán. McFadden, Michael Og. McMenamin, Daniel. Moran, Michael. Morrissey, Michael. Moylan, Seán. Mulcahy, Richard. O Briain, Donnchadh. O Ceallaigh, Seán T. O'Connor, John S. O'Grady, Seán. O'Loghlen, Peter J. O'Neill, Eamonn. O'Reilly, Matthew. O'Rourke, Daniel. Redmond, Bridget M. Reynolds, Mary. Rice, Bridget M. Roddy, Martin. Ryan, James. Ryan, Mary B. Sheridan, Michael. Skinner, Leo B. Smith, Patrick. Traynor, Oscar. Walsh, Laurence. Ward, Conn. | Níl
Beirne, John. Blowick, Joseph. Cafferky, Dominick. Cogan, Patrick. Corish, Richard. Davin, William. Donnellan, Michael. Everett, James. Finucane, Patrick. Flanagan, Oliver J. |
Halliden, Patrick J. Heskin, Denis. Larkin, James (Junior). Murphy, Timothy J. Norton, William. O'Leary, John. O'Sullivan, Martin. Pattison, James P. Spring, Daniel. | Tellers:— Tá: Deputies Kissane and O Briain; Níl: Deputies Murphy and Corish. Question declared carried.
Mr. Donnellan Mr. Donnellan
Mr. Donnellan: They were almost unanimous.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Larkin will now withdraw from the House.
Mr. Larkin (Junior) Mr. Larkin (Junior)
Mr. Larkin (Junior): You can claim credit for another execution, even though it is a small one. Deputy Larkin withdrew.
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
Mr. Finucane: I insist on the right to raise this matter on the Adjournment. I know that Kerins did not get a fair trial.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Finucane should resume his seat.
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
Mr. Finucane: I insist——
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
1227
[1227] An Ceann Comhairle: On a matter which cannot be discussed?
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
Mr. Finucane: I demand——
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: The Deputy seems to demand his own suspension.
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
Mr. Finucane: I demand——
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: The Deputy is quite out of order.
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
Mr. Finucane: I will not resume my seat.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: Then I am constrained to name the Deputy unless he withdraws at once.
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
1228
[1228] Mr. Finucane: I will not withdraw.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: Then I name the Deputy.
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
Mr. Finucane: Well, I will not withdraw. I know he did not get a fair trial.
Mr. Flanagan Mr. Flanagan
Mr. Flanagan: He is not the first innocent man who was hanged.
The Taoiseach Eamon de Valera
The Taoiseach: I move:— That Deputy Finucane be suspended from the service of the Dáil. Question put. The Dáil divided: Tá, 68; Níl, 18. Tá
Aiken, Frank. Allen, Denis. Anthony, Richard S. Bennett, George C. Boland, Patrick. Brady, Brian. Brady, Seán. Breathnach, Cormac. Brennan, Thomas. Breslin, Cormac. Briscoe, Robert. Broderick, William J. Buckley, Seán. Burke, Patrick (Co. Dublin). Butler, Bernard. Carter, Thomas. Childers, Erskine H. Colbert, Michael. Colley, Harry. Corry, Martin J. Cosgrave, Liam. Derrig, Thomas. De Valera, Eamon. Dillon, James M. Dockrell, Henry M. Dockrell, Maurice E. Doyle, Peadar S. Fagan, Charles. Flynn, Stephen. Fogarty, Andrew. Fogarty, Patrick J. Furlong, Walter. Giles, Patrick. Hilliard, Michael. |
Hughes, James. Humphreys, Francis. Keating, John. Kissane, Eamon. Lemass, Seán F. Little, Patrick J. Loughman, Frank. McCann, John. McCarthy, Seán. MacEntee, Seán. McMenamin, Daniel. Moran, Michael. Morrissey, Michael. Moylan, Seán. Mulcahy, Richard. O Briain, Donnchadh. O Ceallaigh, Seán T. O'Connor, John S. O'Grady, Seán. O'Loghlen, Peter J. O'Neill, Eamonn. O'Reilly, Matthew. Redmond, Bridget M. Reynolds, Mary. Rice, Bridget M. Roddy, Martin. Ryan, James. Ryan, Mary B. Sheridan, Michael. Skinner, Leo B. Smith, Patrick. Traynor, Oscar. Walsh, Laurence. Ward, Conn. | Níl
Beirne, John. Blowick, Joseph. Cafferky, Dominick. Cogan, Patrick. Corish, Richard. Davin, William. Donnellan, Michael. Everett, James. Finucane, Patrick. |
Flanagan, Oliver J. Halliden, Patrick J. Heskin, Denis. Murphy, Timothy J. Norton, William. O'Leary, John. O'Sullivan, Martin. Pattison, James P. Spring, Daniel. | Tellers:— Tá, Deputies Kissane and O Briain; Níl: Deputies Blowick and Donnellan. Question declared carried.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
1229
[1229] An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Finucane will now withdraw from the House.
Mr. Finucane Mr. Finucane
Mr. Finucane: There will be another day. I challenge any of the Fianna Fáil Deputies to stand on the Kerins case in Kerry. Deputy Finucane withdrew.
Mr. Spring Mr. Spring
Mr. Spring: I agree with the man who has left the House. I know I will get plenty of interruptions from the Fianna Fáil Benches, but we are entitled to move this matter on the Adjournment to-night.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: The Deputy has no right to intervene now.
Mr. Spring Mr. Spring
Mr. Spring: I stated last night, and I still state, that this young person did not get a fair trial.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
1230
[1230] An Ceann Comhairle: That is quite disorderly.
Mr. Spring Mr. Spring
Mr. Spring: This man is lying in Mountjoy awaiting execution in the morning. We have no one to blame only the Taoiseach. I can certainly say the Taoiseach or any of his Ministers will not be too willing to address a meeting in Kerry in the near future.
Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Thomas Derrig
Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig): Is that a threat?
Mr. Spring Mr. Spring
Mr. Spring: You can take it any way you like.
Mr. Derrig Mr. Derrig
Mr. Derrig: We shall see.
The Taoiseach Eamon de Valera
The Taoiseach: I move:— That Deputy Spring be suspended from the service of the Dáil. Question put. The Dáil divided: Tá, 75; Níl, 18. Tá
Aiken, Frank. Allen, Denis. Anthony, Richard S. Bennett, George C. Blaney, Neal. Boland, Gerald. Boland, Patrick. Brady, Brian. Brady, Seán. Breathnach, Cormac. Brennan, Thomas. Breslin, Cormac. Briscoe, Robert. Broderick, William J. Buckley, Seán. Burke, Patrick (Co. Dublin). Butler, Bernard. Carter, Thomas. Childers, Erskine H. Coburn, James. Colbert, Michael. Colley, Harry. Corry, Martin J. Cosgrave, Liam. Daly, Francis J. Derrig, Thomas. De Valera, Eamon. Dillon, James M. Dockrell, Henry M. Dockrell, Maurice E. Doyle, Peadar S. Fagan, Charles. Flynn, Stephen. Fogarty, Andrew. Fogarty, Patrick J. Furlong, Walter. Giles, Patrick. Harris, Thomas. |
Hilliard, Michael. Hughes, James. Humphreys, Francis. Keating, John. Kilroy, James. Kissane, Eamon. Lemass, Seán F. Little, Patrick J. Loughman, Frank. McCann, John. McCarthy, Seán. MacEntee, Seán. McFadden, Michael Og. McMenamin, Daniel. Moran, Michael. Morrissey, Michael. Moylan, Seán. Mulcahy, Richard. O Briain, Donnchadh. O Ceallaigh, Seán T. O'Connor, John S. O'Grady, Seán. O'Loghlen, Peter J. O'Neill, Eamonn. O'Reilly, Matthew. O'Rourke, Daniel. Redmond, Bridget M. Reynolds, Mary. Rice, Bridget M. Roddy, Martin. Ryan, James. Ryan, Mary B. Sheridan, Michael. Skinner, Leo B. Traynor, Oscar. Walsh, Laurence. Ward, Conn. | Níl
|
1231
[1231]Beirne, John. Blowick, Joseph. Cafferky, Dominick. Cogan, Patrick. Corish, Richard. Davin, William. Donnellan, Michael. Everett, James. Flanagan, Oliver J. |
1232
[1232]Halliden, Patrick J. Heskin, Denis. Keyes, Michael. Murphy, Timothy J. Norton, William. O'Leary, John. O'Sullivan, Martin. Pattison, James P. Spring, Daniel. | Tellers:—Tá: Deputies Kissane and O Briain; Níl: Deputies Everett and Pattison. Question declared carried.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Spring is suspended from the service of the Dáil and will now leave the House.
Mr. Spring Mr. Spring
Mr. Spring: I am leaving the House through a coalition vote between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: By a decision of the House.
Mr. Spring Mr. Spring
Mr. Spring: Fine Gael has 77 murders in Kerry and Fianna Fáil has now nearly as many.
An Ceann Comhairle Frank Fahy
An Ceann Comhairle: It is the decision of the House. Deputy Spring withdrew.
Dáil Éireann
95
Suspension of Deputies.
General Debate
19441130
|
